Home / The Digital Dollar / The CLARITY Act Explained: What It Does and Where It Stands

The CLARITY Act Explained: What It Does and Where It Stands

The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act would decide which regulator oversees which tokens. It cleared the House in 2025 and failed a Senate procedural vote by one vote in September 2026.

The short answer

The CLARITY Act (H.R. 3633, the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act) is a bill to set federal rules for digital asset markets. It would give the CFTC oversight of spot trading in "digital commodities" and leave the SEC in charge of token fundraising and securities. It passed the House 294 to 134 on 17 July 2025. On 15 September 2026 a Senate cloture vote failed 49 to 50, and a motion to reconsider is pending. It is not law.

What the CLARITY Act is for

H.R. 3633 was introduced in the House on 29 May 2025 and sent to two committees, Financial Services and Agriculture, because it reaches into the territory of two regulators. The Securities and Exchange Commission oversees securities. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission oversees commodity futures and, in narrower ways, commodity markets.

Digital assets sit awkwardly between them. Whether a token is a security has been decided under the Supreme Court's 1946 Howey test, which asks whether buyers invested money in a common enterprise expecting profits from the efforts of others. The SEC's own March 2026 interpretive release notes that the agency applied that test mostly through enforcement actions, an approach some commissioners and commentators called "regulation by enforcement".

The CLARITY Act would replace case-by-case answers with definitions written into statute, a registration regime for trading platforms, and rules for when a token stops being treated as part of a securities offering.

How the House bill splits the SEC and the CFTC

The House-passed text turns on one new term. A digital commodity is a digital asset "intrinsically linked to a blockchain system" whose value comes, or is expected to come, from use of that system. The bill does not name any coin.

Who would oversee what under the House-passed CLARITY Act (H.R. 3633, July 2025)
ActivityRegulatorWhat the bill does
Spot trading of digital commoditiesCFTCExclusive jurisdiction over cash and spot transactions on registered platforms; new registration for digital commodity exchanges, brokers and dealers
Raising money by selling tokensSECOfferings remain investment contracts; a new exemption allows an issuer to raise up to $50 million in any 12 months, adjusted for inflation
When a network is "mature"SECA blockchain is mature when no person or group under common control controls it, certified under section 42 of the Securities Exchange Act
Payment stablecoinsBank regulators under the GENIUS Act, plus SEC anti-fraud authorityStablecoins from permitted issuers keep their GENIUS Act treatment
Decentralized financeExcludedExclusions for certain software and protocol activities

The exemption comes with a clock. A project can rely on it only if its blockchain is already mature or the issuer intends it to become mature within four years. The design assumes a token starts out dependent on its developers, when securities-style protections fit, and moves toward commodity treatment as control spreads out.

The House bill also carried a sixth title, the Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act. It would have barred Federal Reserve Banks from offering accounts or financial products directly to individuals and from issuing a central bank digital currency.

The House vote

The House passed H.R. 3633 by 294 to 134 on 17 July 2025 (Roll Call 199). 216 Republicans and 78 Democrats voted yes; 134 Democrats voted no. It was one of three digital asset bills the House passed that day, under a single rule:

  • The GENIUS Act (S. 1582), passed 308 to 122 and signed the next day as Public Law 119-27.
  • The CLARITY Act (H.R. 3633), passed 294 to 134.
  • The Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act (H.R. 1919), passed 219 to 210. The Senate never voted on it.

Only the stablecoin bill became law that summer. Our guide to the GENIUS Act covers what it requires of issuers.

What the Senate Banking Committee changed

The Senate received the bill on 18 September 2025 and referred it to the Banking Committee. The committee voted to report it on 14 May 2026, and Senator Tim Scott reported it to the floor on 1 June 2026 with a full substitute text (Calendar No. 423). The substitute is a different bill in several respects:

  • New token categories. A network token is treated as a non-security for the securities laws. An ancillary asset is a network token whose value still depends on the managerial efforts of the person who launched it, and it carries disclosure duties.
  • No CBDC title. The anti-CBDC provisions are gone. A separate CBDC ban became law on 11 July 2026 as Title XI of Public Law 119-101.
  • Stablecoin rewards. Section 404 bars exchanges and other digital asset service providers, and their affiliates, from paying US customers interest or yield solely for holding payment stablecoins, or in a way equivalent to interest on a bank deposit. Rewards based on bona fide activities or transactions would remain allowed under rules to be written within a year.
  • Self-custody. The Keep Your Coins Act section would stop federal agencies from prohibiting or restricting an individual's ability to hold digital assets in a self-hosted wallet and use them for any lawful purpose.
  • Temporary holds. Section 305 would shield firms from private lawsuits when they voluntarily freeze a digital asset transaction they reasonably believe is illegal, or do so at law enforcement's written request.

The Banking text covers the securities side. The Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC, reported its own measure, S. 3755, the Digital Commodity Intermediaries Act, on 2 February 2026. It has been on the Senate calendar since.

Where it stands on 28 October 2026

A motion to proceed to H.R. 3633 and a cloture motion were filed on 8 August 2026. On 15 September 2026 the Senate voted 49 to 50 on cloture, short of the 60 votes needed to end debate on the motion to proceed (Roll Call 234). One senator did not vote. Senator Thom Tillis, who voted no, then entered a motion to reconsider, which allows the Senate to vote again on the same cloture motion. Senators Jerry Moran and Martin Heinrich filed amendments the same day.

The bill status record on govinfo.gov, last updated 17 September 2026, shows no further action. For the bill to become law, the Senate would need 60 votes to proceed and then to pass a text. Because that text would differ from the House version, the House would have to agree to it before it went to the President.

Regulators have kept moving in the meantime. The SEC's interpretive release on how the securities laws apply to digital assets, issued with CFTC guidance, took effect on 23 March 2026 and sorts tokens into categories. On 13 October 2026 the CFTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking on rules for retail transactions and markets in digital assets under its existing authority, with comments due by 14 December 2026. An interpretation or rule can be revised by a later commission. A statute can be changed only by Congress, and that durability is the main argument for legislating.

Our CBDC and stablecoin tracker records each vote and status change on H.R. 3633.

What the bill would change for savers

Most of the CLARITY Act governs firms, not households. Its effects on an individual would come through the platforms they use:

  • Exchanges and brokers dealing in digital commodities would register with the CFTC or the SEC and meet custody, disclosure and conflict-of-interest rules.
  • Tokens would carry a legal label, security or digital commodity, instead of waiting for an enforcement case to supply one.
  • Under the Senate text, interest-like rewards on stablecoin balances held at exchanges would end, which matters to anyone treating a dollar stablecoin as a cash account. Our guide to how stablecoins work explains why issuers already cannot pay yield.
  • Self-custody would gain explicit federal protection, while platforms would gain legal cover for freezing suspect transfers.

Those last two pull in opposite directions on control of money, and both are in the same Senate text. Until the Senate acts, none of it applies.

ChartCBDC and Stablecoin TrackerEvery country's CBDC stage, the US rules and stablecoin supply.Open the chart

Questions readers ask

Is the CLARITY Act law?

No. It passed the House 294 to 134 on 17 July 2025. In the Senate, a cloture vote on the motion to proceed failed 49 to 50 on 15 September 2026, and a motion to reconsider that vote is pending. There has been no further floor action as of 28 October 2026.

Does the CLARITY Act ban a central bank digital currency?

The House-passed version included the Anti-CBDC Surveillance State Act as Title VI. The Senate Banking Committee's substitute dropped it. A separate ban on a Fed-issued CBDC became law on 11 July 2026 as Title XI of Public Law 119-101 and expires on 31 December 2030.

What is a digital commodity under the CLARITY Act?

In the House text, a digital asset intrinsically linked to a blockchain system whose value is derived, or reasonably expected to be derived, from use of that system. Spot trading in digital commodities on registered platforms would fall under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction.

What is the difference between the CLARITY Act and the GENIUS Act?

The GENIUS Act, law since 18 July 2025, regulates payment stablecoins and their issuers. The CLARITY Act would regulate the wider market: how other tokens are classified, who supervises the exchanges and brokers that trade them, and, in the Senate version, rewards paid on stablecoin balances.

Why did the Senate vote fail?

Cloture needs 60 votes, and the motion received 49, with 50 against and one senator absent. The vote was on whether to begin debate. It was not a vote on final passage, and the pending motion to reconsider allows the Senate to hold it again.

Sources

  1. US Government Publishing Office: Bill status, H.R. 3633 (119th Congress)
  2. US Government Publishing Office: H.R. 3633 as passed by the House (engrossed text)
  3. US Government Publishing Office: H.R. 3633 as reported in the Senate, 1 June 2026
  4. Office of the Clerk, US House of Representatives: Roll Call 199 on H.R. 3633, 17 July 2025
  5. Congressional Record: Senate cloture vote on the motion to proceed to H.R. 3633, Rollcall Vote No. 234, 15 September 2026
  6. US Government Publishing Office: Bill status, S. 3755, Digital Commodity Intermediaries Act
  7. US Securities and Exchange Commission: Release No. 33-11412, interpretation on the application of the federal securities laws to certain digital assets (effective 23 March 2026)
  8. Federal Register: CFTC advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 64811 (13 October 2026)
  9. US Government Publishing Office: Public Law 119-101, Title XI: Central Bank Digital Currency

The bigger picture, every Monday

One research brief on the dollar, the debt and the assets being repriced around them.

By subscribing, you will receive complimentary access to The Bear Case and Alternative Insider News, including market commentary, research, special reports, and occasional promotional messages. You may unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy | Terms.